New York Pizza of Redlands

Enjoy authentic New York-style pizza at New York Pizza of Redlands! Delicious calzones, crispy crust, flavorful toppings, sausage, eggplant parm, and more. Order today at 535 W State St, Redlands, CA or call +1 909-798-8389!

View MenuContact

Welcome to New York Pizza of Redlands

Experience the finest dining

New York Pizza of Redlands
New York Pizza of Redlands
New York Pizza of Redlands
New York Pizza of Redlands

New York Pizza of Redlands welcomes pizza lovers to enjoy a slice of authentic New York-style pizza right in the heart of Redlands. Located at 535 W State St, this cozy spot offers a laid-back vibe and a menu filled with delicious options that will satisfy any craving. The owner takes pride in crafting each dish, using high-quality ingredients and generous toppings. From traditional pizzas to hearty calzones and comforting entrees, every bite transports you to the streets of New York City.

Popular favorites include the eggplant parm and loaded potato wedges, perfect for sharing or indulging solo. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, this pizzeria becomes a community staple for pizza enthusiasts.

This pizzeria boasts a wide variety of menu options perfect for any occasion. The menu features 71 items across several categories like appetizers, salads, New York specialty pizzas, entrées, and sandwiches. Try the garlic bread sticks or jalapeño poppers to kick off your meal. For those craving something lighter, the garden salad with chicken is refreshing and satisfying. New York Pizza of Redlands excels with its specialty pizzas, including the Sicilian and BBQ chicken varieties, each crafted to deliver robust flavors.

The calzones are not to be missed, providing a delightful twist to the traditional pizza experience. Prices remain incredibly reasonable, averaging just $7.93 per dish, making it an excellent choice for families and friends. Plus, the option of pairing your meal with a refreshing beer or wine enhances the dining experience.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

535 W State St, Redlands, CA 92373, United States

Phone

+1 909-798-8389

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

New York Pizza of Redlands
New York Pizza of Redlands
New York Pizza of Redlands
New York Pizza of Redlands

New York Pizza of Redlands stands out not only for its food but also for its commitment to the community. This pizzeria not only provides delicious meals but serves as a gathering place for friends and families. The ambiance combines a casual dining experience with welcoming service, making every visit feel like coming home. The restaurant shines busiest on Wednesdays at 11 AM, attracting pizza lovers eager to enjoy their famous crust and ample toppings.

Each dish embodies a slice of New York culture, whether it’s the classic New Yorker pizza or the savory eggplant parmigiana. Customers appreciate the generous portions and reasonable pricing, creating an accessible dining option for everyone. The restaurant has developed a loyal following, with patrons frequently returning for their favorites and new visitors drawn in by the vibrant community buzz that surrounds the eatery.

Additionally, the restaurant actively participates in local events and fundraisers, deepening its connection to Redlands. It's more than just pizza; it’s about building relationships and fostering a sense of belonging. The commitment to quality and community ensures that each meal feels special, whether dining in, taking out, or ordering for a large gathering.

New York Pizza of Redlands

The exterior of New York Pizza of Redlands features an inviting storefront with warm colors that beckon passersby. The casual outdoor seating provides perfect opportunities for dining al fresco, especially during pleasant California evenings. Customers appreciate the relaxed atmosphere that reflects the bustling energy of New York City while remaining true to the local vibe of Redlands. It's common to see families enjoying slices at outdoor tables, sharing good food and laughter. The surrounding area adds to the experience, with the pizzeria nestled amidst local shops and friendly neighborhoods, contributing to its charm.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday3-7 PM
  • Monday11 AM-7 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-7 PM
  • Friday11 AM-7:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-7:30 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

I ordered a calzone with pepperoni, sausage, and black olives. In addition, I ordered a drink and mozzarella sticks. The mozz sticks weren't the best but the calzone was AMAZING. Probably one of the best I've had in a hot minute. It would have bee nice to have one of the televisions on. The restaurant was totally silent - kinda depressing. I will say there was plenty of comfort seating and the restaurant was very clean. Super nice couple running the joint. The neighborhoodis nice too. I'd recommend it! I be back to try to pizza.

M
Matthew M.

This has been one of the best pizza spots i've found in Redlands so far! Amazing pizza and I love their potato wedges and ranch!

A
Anna

Some of the best pizza I've had so far. So good.

I
Isiah E.

Great pizza and service. Clean, nice, and cool. Honestly, the best pizza we have ever had- and we are old, so we have had many pizzas. Prices were great, and again, the service was impeccable. It would be nice to have music or something, as it was so quiet! Needs more "ambiance," but still the best pizza!

R
Rosanna W.

We went here to get pepperoni pizzas for a kids birthday party because Domino's is way too expensive. The kids at the party were very picky and on the spectrum, so food choices were limited. I am happy to report that the family-sized one-topping pepperoni is not only buried in pepperoni, but was a big hit with all of the kids. Even my super-picky daughter with ARFID ate some, which was emotional for me as she has refused to eat pizza for over two years. For this reason, this place gets 5 stars from me .

a
andi n.

Found out about this place because I'm pregnant and wanted ny pizza so I googled. I wish we would have found it sooner. Their sandwich were awesome and pizza amazing!

S
Samantha N.