New York Pizza of Redlands Menu (Update 2026)

Located at 535 W State St, Redlands, CA, New York Pizza of Redlands serves authentic New York-style pizza that locals rave about. With over 70 dishes, this menu offers something for everyone's palate, from savory specialty pizzas to hearty entrées. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for family dinners or casual hangouts with friends. Give in to your cravings and explore the rich variety they offer, as the average meal is priced around $7.93, ensuring delicious food without breaking the bank.

Appetizers
Salads
New York Specialty Pizzas
Entrées
BEER & WINE
Calzone
Sandwiches
Soup
Specialty Sandwiches
Beverages
Desserts
Party Trays
Pizzas
Sides
New York Pizza of Redlands Menu image 1
New York Pizza of Redlands Menu image 2
New York Pizza of Redlands

New York Pizza of Redlands: Interior, Food, Ambiance

The interior of New York Pizza of Redlands exudes comfort and charm, making it an ideal dining destination. The warm colors and cozy booths create a welcoming vibe where friends and families can gather. As you dig into a slice of their famous pizza, enjoy the lively atmosphere that fills the air with the enticing aroma of freshly baked pies. With sports often playing on the screens and locals chatting, the ambiance feels just right for enjoying good food and great company. No wonder many make this eatery their go-to spot in Redlands.

New York Pizza of Redlands

About New York Pizza of Redlands' Food and Specialties

New York Pizza of Redlands excels with its diverse menu. Customers often highlight the New York-style pizzas, crispy calzones, and flavorful entrées. The pizza toppings take center stage, with favorites like sausage, eggplant parmesan, and a variety of fresh vegetables. Try the garlic breadsticks as an appetizer or the hearty cheese-filled calzone for a filling delight. Don't overlook the salads, either; the Antipasto Salad is a refreshing choice that pairs perfectly with the rich flavors of the pizzas. This establishment leaves no stone unturned when it comes to satisfying every craving my fellow Redlands friends might have.

New York Pizza of Redlands

New York Pizza of Redlands exemplifies a commitment to quality, community, and culinary excellence. The vision is clear: to create an inviting space where everyone can enjoy delicious pizza made from the freshest ingredients. Their specialty lies in New York-style pizza, known for its thin, crispy crust and abundant toppings. This dedication ensures that each pie is a work of art, whether it’s topped with classic sausage, rich cheese, or hearty eggplant parmigiana.

The restaurant strives to create lasting memories through food while engaging with the local community. With every slice served, New York Pizza of Redlands emphasizes its role as a beloved local establishment.